Determination of a Solubility Product Constant

 

Abstract:  The solubility product constant (Ksp) of potassium hydrogen tartrate (KHC4H4O6 , “Cream of Tartar” ) will be evaluated by determining the concentration of hydrogen tartrate ion (HC4H4O6- ) in a saturated solution of potassium hydrogen tartrate by titration with sodium hydroxide.  You may have seen crystals of this compound on corks from white wine bottles.

 

Introduction

 

The solubility product constant, Ksp:  When an ionic solid is added to pure water, it dissolves at a relatively rapid initial rate.  But as the concentration of dissolved ions increases, so does the rate of reprecipitation.  Soon the rate of reprecipitation equals the rate of dissolution, and there is no more net dissolution of solid.  The state of dynamic equilibrium has been attained.  Of course, there may be very rapid dissolution and reprecipitation, evidenced by changes in the shape of particles of solid, even though their masses remain the same.

 

For an ionic compound, the equation for dissolution is

 

(1)        AnBm(s) Û  n Am+(aq) + m Bn-(aq)

 

When equilibrium has been attained, the solution is said to be saturated.  If solid is added to the mixture of solid and solution at equilibrium, none will dissolve; if solid is removed, the concentration of ions in solution will remain the same.  Since the presence of solid has no effect on the equilibrium concentrations of ions in the saturated solution, the equilibrium constant expression for equation (1) does not include a term referring to the solid.   The equilibrium constant is called the solubility product constant, and it is defined as

 

(2)        Ksp  = [Am+]n[Bn-]m

 

The solubility product constant is extremely useful for predicting solubilities of salts not only in pure water, but in solutions which already contain one or the other of the ions in the dissolving substance. For example, potassium hydrogen pththallate, HC8H4O4, is a slightly soluble ionic compound whose structure is shown to the right.  We can look up the solubility of potassium hydrogen phthallate in the CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics, and find it to be 10 g per 100 mL of water at 25oC.

 

The Ksp can be calculated from the solubility as follows:

            The concentration of a saturated solution (at equilibrium) is:

(3)       

 

Since KHC8H4O4 dissolves and dissociates almost completely to give K+ ions and HC8H4O4- ions, the concentration of each ion is also .49 M, and Ksp is:

 

(4)        Ksp = [K+][HC8H4O4-] = (.49)(.49) = .24

 

It might seem that stating the solubility is simpler and more efficient than stating the value of Ksp.  But having the value of Ksp is really much more useful than having the solubility, because with it solubilities in solutions containing "common ions" can be calculated.  For example, we can calculate the solubility of potassium hydrogen phthallate in a solution already containg 4 M KCl:

 

 

                             KHC8H4O4         Û                         K+        +                 HC8H4O4-

init. C(M)                                                                       4 M                         0

change                                                                          + x                          + x

eq. C(M)                                                                        4 + x                       x

 

                             Ksp = .24 = [4 + x][x] @  [4][x]

 

                             x = .06 M

 

                             .06 mol/L x 204 g/mol = 12 g/L

 

or only 1.2 g in 100 mL, compared to the solubility of 10 g in 100 mL of pure water.

 

 

Potassium Hydrogen Tartrate:  The substance used in this experiment has had a profound impact on both the technological and  theoretical development of chemistry.  Cooks call it "cream of tartar."

Oenologists (wine experts) and producers sometimes use the German name "weins¬ure" (wine acid) or "wine lees" for this solid, which precipitates during the fermentation of grapes.  Grapes, like may fruits, are high in this natural "fruit acid", with the formula KHC4H4O6, whose structure is shown to the right.   Traces of calcium tartrate found in a pottary jar from ruins of a neolithic village in northern Iran have been used as evidence that wine was being produced 7000 years ago[1], because the only significant natural source of tartaric acid is grapes.

Cream of tartar is used as a source of acid in home-made baking powder, which also contains sodium hydrogen carbonate.  When moist, they react to give CO2 which causes breads to rise:

 

(5)        HC4H4O6- + HCO3- Û  C4H4O62- + H2CO3

 

(6)        H2CO3 Û  H2O  + CO2(g)

 

Many cooks find cream of tartar superior to the sodium aluminum sulfate (NaAlSO4) which is the acid used in modern "double-acting" baking powders. 

Potassium hydrogen tartrate is the "salt" obtained when tartaric acid (H2C4H4O6) is half neutralized with potassium hydroxide:

 

(7)        H2C4H4O6 + KOH  Û  H2O  +  KHC4H4O6

 

Louis Pasteur revolutionized our understanding of molecular structure when he found two kinds of tartaric acid crystals forming in fermenting grapes, both having the same formula.  The two forms are identical except that their molecules are mirror images of one another, like your right and left hand.  The forms differ in the direction which they rotate polarized light, and only the dextrotartaric acid (right-rotating) is found in most living things.  Tartaric acid is used in soft drinks, candies, bakery products, tanning, photography, and in gelatin desserts.  Tartaric acid or potassium hydrogen tartrate was called faecula ("little yeast") by the Romans, and the derivation of the word from "Tartarus" (in Greek mythology, the abysmal regions of hell, below Hades) is of alchemical origin.  Our interest in potassium hydrogen tartrate is an ancient one.

 

Most commercial potassium hydrogen tartrate is obtained from the sediments in the manufacture of wine.  Knowing the value of Ksp  and how to apply it is important to our understanding of the fermentation technology.

 

Method

 

            A saturated solution of potassium hydrogen tartrate is prepared by stirring KHT in water for 20 minutes so that the following equilibrium is attained:

 

(8)        KHT(s) Û  K+ + HT- 

 

Where HT- represents the hydrogen tartrate ion, HC4H4O6-.  The concentrations of K+ and HT- are needed to evaluate Ksp.

 

(9)        Ksp = [K+][HT-]

 

The hydrogen tartrate or bitartrate ion concentration is determined by titration with NaOH:

 

(10)      C4O6H5- + OH-  Û  C4O6H42- + H2O

 

The solid KHT must be removed by filtration before the solution is titrated, otherwise reaction (8) will provide HT- as the OH- consumes it, and all the KHT will dissolve.

            The amount (in mol) of bitartrate is equal to the amount of hydroxide, which is calculated from the volume of sodium hydroxide standard solution used in the titration:

 

(11)      n(mol) = C(M) x V(L)

 

If the potassium bitartrate is dissolved in pure water, the concentration of potassium ion must be equal to the concentration of bitartrate ion, and Ksp can be calculated:

 

(12)      Ksp = [K+][HT-] = [HT-]2

 

If the potassium bitartrate is dissolved in 0.l0 M potassium chloride solution, the "common ion" K+ should (by LeChatelier's Principle) lower the solubility of the potassium bitartrate.  Because the value of Ksp is constant, increasing the concentration of one ion must decrease the concentration of the other.  In this case, the concentration of bitartrate is determined as above, but the concentration of potassium ion is 0.1 M + [HT-], so the value of Ksp is

 

(13)      Ksp = [K+][HT-] = (0.10 + [HT-])[HT-]

 

 

Prelaboratory Assignment

Procedural:

1.  Suppose 1.5 g (rather than 1.0 g) of potassium hydrogen tartrate is mixed with 75 mL of water or KCl solution in steps 1 and 2 of the procedure.  Would this increase, decrease, or have no effect on the value of Ksp?

 

2.  In step 3 of the procedure, the filter paper and holder used to filter the KHT solution must be clean and dry, but the beaker used to collect the KHT from the burette in step 4 need not be dry.  Why will water cause an error in the first case and not in the second?

 

Theoretical:

3.  If water at the boiling point is saturated with potassium hydrogen tartrate, 30 mL of the solution requires 49.5 mL of 0.2 M NaOH in a titration.  What is the Ksp of potassium hydrogen tartrate at this temperature, and what is the solubility in g/L?

 

4.  At a certain temperature, 16.7 mL of 0.45 M NaOH solution is required to titrate 30.0 mL of a 0.1 M KCl solution saturated with potassium bitartrate.  What is the Ksp of KHT at this temperature?

 

5.  A student realized that the after KHT dissolves, bitartrate ion might be involved in the equilibrium

 

(14)      HT- + H2O  Û  H2T + OH-

 

The HT- would then not be available for titration with NaOH, and misleading results would be obtained.  Why has the student reached an incorrect conclusion (all the HT- will be titrated even though reaction (14) may, in fact, proceed)?

 

Procedure:

 

1.  Tare a 150 or 250 mL beaker on the balance, add about 1 g of finely ground potassium hydrogen tartrate ("KHT"), and record the mass.    Repeat for a second sample.

 

2.  Add 75 mL of distilled water and a magnetic stirrer to one of the flasks containing KHT, and add 75 mL of 0.10 M KCl to the other.   Stir the first flask for a sufficient time to saturate the water with KHT.  At room temperature this may require 10 minutes.    If a magnetic stirrer is not available, swirl the flasks every minute or two.  If a magnetic stirrer is used, transfer it to the second flask after the first one has been stirred for about 10 minutes.

 

3.  Assemble a Luer-lok filter assembly with a dry 2.1 cm filter disk.  Draw as much of the KHT suspension as possible into a 20 or 60 mL syringe, attach the syringe to the filter apparatus, and eject 10-15 mL of the solution into a burette.  Rinse the burette with the solution and discard it.  Fill the burette with the remaining solution from the syringe/filter apparatus.  Remove the syringe from the filter to refill it when necessary, to provide enough solution to fill the burette.   Open the stopcock briefly to eliminate bubbles from the burette.

 

4.  Use the burette to deliver at least 35 mL of the KHT solution to a clean (but not necesarily dry) 250 mL beaker or Erlenmeyer flask.    Record the precisely measured volume.

 

5.  Repeat steps 3 and 4 for the solution of KHT in 0.1 M KCl.

 

6.  Rinse and fill a clean burette with 0.05 to .1 M standard NaOH solution.  Make sure that no air bubbles are trapped in the stopcock.    Add a few drops of phenolphthalein indicator to the KHT solutions, titrate them with NaOH, and record the volumes.

 

 

Equipment and Supplies

 

(2) 50 mL burettes                                            (2) 250 mL Erlenmeyer flasks

(2) 150 mL beakers                                          60 mL plastic syringe

magnetic stirrer                                     burette stand and clamp

phenolphthalein indicator                                   Luer-lok Syringe filter holder and filter paper

0.4 g potassium hydrogen tartrate                      150 mL 0.10 M KI or KCl      

50 mL 0.050 M standard NaOH solution

 

Projects:

I.  Free Energy (DG), Entropy change (DS) and Enthalpy of solution for KHTar:  Repeat the experiment, but dissolve the KHTar in water at different temperatures[2].  Determine the equilibrium constant at 0oC.  Repeat at a higher temperature as well to see if the same trend is observed.  If the reaction is exothermic, decreasing the temperature should increase the value of Ksp, but the value as well as the sign of DH can be determined from the equation which predicts how K changes with T:

 

           OR      

 

Where K1 and K2 are the equilibrium constants at temperatures T1 and T2 (Kelvins), and R is the ideal gas constant, 8.31 J/mol K.  If measurements are made at several temperatures, the second equation shows that a plot of ln K vs. 1/T should be a straight line with slope -DH/R. 

            Does the sign of DH agree with predictions from LeChatelier’s Principle?  Does its value reflect involvement of a large amount of bond energy (DH reflects formation and destruction of bonds as long as DV for the reaction is small, when DH» DE).

 

II.  Calculation of DG and DS for the reaction:  The value of the free energy change, DG, can be calculated from the equilibrium constant:

                       

and DS can be calculated from DH (calculated in Project I) and DG, by using the Gibbs Equation :

                       

Interpret the value of DS:  In terms of increases or decreases in disorder, explain the relationship between DS and the chemical equation for what is actually happening.

 

III.  Radiochemical Determination of the Ksp of Ba(OH)2:  In an earlier experiment, we eluted Ba-137 from a minigenerator and determined it’s halflife.  That same Ba-137 could be used as a radiochemical tracer to determine the Ksp for barium hydroxide.  The total count for 10-20 drops of eluent in a planchette should be determined and the time recorded.  The tracer solution might be washed into a 30 mL beaker with 2 mL of 2.0  M Ba(NO3)2 “carrier,” then 2 mL of 2-4 M NaOH added to precipitate the Ba(OH)2.  Stirring for a few minutes with a stirring rod coated with previously-precipitated Ba(OH)2 is sometimes necessary to accelerate this slow process.  The suspension is then drawn into a syringe, a LuerLok filter attached, and after a few drops are discarded, 20 drops of filtrate are added to a planchette and counted, and the time recorded.  The precipitate could also be counted.  Repeat counts (and times) of the filtrate could be used to confirm the halflife.

            The carrier is added because radiotracers are present at chemically insignificant concentrations (only a few thousand atoms in many cases).  Barium nitrate is added so that a substantial amount of precipitate is obtained rapidly.  The ratio of activity in the filtrate to the total activity can be multiplied by the total number of moles of Ba2+ present to give the amount (in mols) in solution, and thence the concentration at equilibrium.  The initial concentration is calculated from the known concentration of the barium nitrate and total volume of the mixture.  All counts must be adjusted to the same time by using the equation ln(A/Ao) = -kt, so that the effects of decay during the experiment are eliminated, and you must work fairly quickly.

            II.  Titrimetric Determination of the Ksp of Ba(OH)2.  In an earlier experiment, we did a conductimetric titration of Ba(OH)2 to determine the stoichiometry of the reaction with H2SO4.  The same procedure could be adapted to a measurement of Ksp for barium hydroxide.  About 1 mL of a saturated solution could be titrated.

 

Footnotes



[1] P.E. McGovern, Nature, 381, 480 (1996).

[2] Silberman, R.G., J. Chem. Educ. 73, 426 (1996).