Journal of Chemical Education

Tested Demonstrations Evaluation

Checker # ____ MS # __________________

Title:

Checker: Please be sure to address all of the following questions in your evaluation of this demonstration (either include them in your comments or check the appropriate boxes below and return this form, or both)

1. What is/are the appropriate level(s) for this demo? – Elementary – High School – College/Univ	5. How well could this demonstration be projected? – Very well – Adequately – Poorly
2. How difficult is it to perform? – Simple – Average –   Difficult 3. Are equipment and materials readily available? –Yes – No (list any problems) 4. Relationship of audience size to material size or volume – how visible is the entire procedure to the entire audience? –Good –Adequate –Poor	6. How well does it elucidate a concept? – Very well – Adequately – Poorly 7. Are similar demonstrations easily available? –No –Yes (list relevant references) 8. Is this more or less useful than similar ones? – More – No different – Less – Not applicable 9. Are all safety and disposal concerns adequately addressed? – Yes –No (list omissions)

Overall recommendation:

– Definitely publish – Definitely do not publish

– Publish after revision to address problems – Probably not publishable

– Should be published elsewhere; for example in __________________________________________

The reviewer information section below will be removed or masked before the comments are sent to the author Use additional pages if needed.

Checked by:___________________________

Telephone: 610-683-4443

Fax: 610-683-1352 email: _________________________________

e-mail: vitz@kutztown.edu signed: ________________________________